Study finds some road closures cause less congestion
See all news![Cars on the street](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/news-road-closures-760x300.jpg?la=en&h=300&w=760&mw=847&hash=260C084D6190B7DF42AEDA1B99E8597C)
Two researchers from the University of the West of England (UWE Bristol) have published a study shedding new light on why traffic is sometimes reduced when certain city roads are closed by the Council. Dr Steve Melia and Dr Tom Calvert from UWE Bristol’s Centre for Transport and Society found that if main or ‘strategic’ roads were closed, some drivers decided to stop using their cars and instead used different forms of transport, or changed their travel habits.
Since the first lockdown, many councils have been closing roads to car traffic, converting them to pedestrian walkways or reserving them for buses and bikes. For the study, the researchers looked at other similar trends from evidence around Europe, and two recent examples in Southwest England.
Earlier studies had shown that when roads were closed, some of the traffic usually ‘disappeared’ but until this latest study the reasons behind this were uncertain. Steve Melia, who is Senior Lecturer in planning and transport, said: “We found that if you close a local road with easy alternatives, nearly all the traffic is displaced onto those surrounding roads and there may be no traffic reduction.
“But if you close a strategic road, causing a big detour, then some of the traffic does ‘disappear.’ Traffic volumes go down, partly because congestion increases, at least in the short-term. Some people switch to public transport, walking or cycling, while others travel less or go somewhere else. In the longer-term, there’s some evidence that traffic volumes continue to fall, gradually reducing the congestion.”
He added: “This creates a dilemma for local authorities. The easy road closures might help to improve the feel of a street, but they do nothing to reduce traffic. The bigger, more controversial closures do cause some congestion, at least to start off with, but they’re the ones that bring the benefits of less traffic across the city.”
An example of a local road with easy alternative is the pedestrianisation of St James street in Taunton town centre in 2019, which is featured in the research. Some 98% of the drivers who used to drive along St James Street continued to drive to the same place but took a slightly longer route. There was little evidence of behaviour change and no traffic reduction.
That same year, in the centre of Bristol, a five-day demonstration on Bristol Bridge caused the strategic closure of the bridge, the only route for traffic to cross the city centre. The alternative routes were longer and already congested. Over the five days of demonstration, congestion increased slightly and the volume of traffic fell by seven per cent in the city centre and two percent across the rest of the city. Bristol City Council has since installed a bus gate on Bristol Bridge, permanently removing cars and vans.
Research Fellow Tom Calvert said: “The Taunton project had to adapt to fewer roads being pedestrianised than expected. It was a reminder of the constraints and objections that pedestrianisation schemes can encounter. Nonetheless, the combination of the two studies made a valuable contribution to understanding the realities of traffic displacement and reduction.”
The research also used evidence on the pedestrianisation of the right bank of the River Seine in Paris in 2016 (already published but not in English). This showed a similar pattern to the Bristol example, but the authorities found a different reaction in the short and medium terms. Over the following year, traffic volumes on the surrounding roads continued to fall.
Related news
![Someone holds the world in their hands in a pool of water](/-/media/uwe/images/news/climate-theatre-project-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=671411EFE5D11C702F789A85526F61DF)
26 June 2024
Water security and climate action to be explored through theatre with communities
UWE Bristol will support an international research project that will embed theatre practice to work with less heard communities who face water insecurity.
![A photo of a sign which says general election 2024 with Big Ben in the background](/-/media/uwe/images/news/general-election-adobestock-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=32EF3AB7949BAEE17613D57B04C55384)
17 June 2024
Opinion: Stats, leaflets, and claims - how to navigate the political battlefield
As political leaflets begin to clog the letterboxes of homes across the UK, how can you discern the truth amidst the claims made by the political parties?
![Members of the Centre for Appearance Research standing for a group photo, with balloons in the background](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/car-anniversary-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=DB550ACB3604EBA25099B9C3D3944EDC)
24 May 2024
Impact of world-leading Centre for Appearance Research celebrated on 30th anniversary
It has grown from two researchers and a PhD student to become what is considered the largest research centre in the world focussed on appearance and body image. Now the Centre for Appearance Research (CAR) has celebrated its 30th anniversary.
![Centre for Appearance Research logo in front of a backdrop of the city docks in Bristol](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/appearance-matters-banner-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=12AF26A023C1FCD612FF8DC455319B40)
22 May 2024
Psychology researchers set to stage world’s only international conference on appearance and body image
Researchers from UWE Bristol are getting ready to stage the world’s only international conference focused on issues around appearance and body image.
![A photographer using an old-fashioned camera to take an photo of Stonehenge, with a backdrop of a blue sky](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/stonehenge-photography-main-image-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=82D3AA342D3552BF0055E5180A7BFE8E)
22 May 2024
Academic retraces footsteps of Victorian photography pioneer behind Led Zeppelin album cover
A UWE Bristol researcher has used old-fashioned photography methods to recreate images by a Victorian photographer noted for taking an iconic photo that became a Led Zeppelin album cover.
![A choir, dressed in black, singing](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/sing-for-happiness-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=93348AAAB0FE92C6F3A08BF25933D518)
22 May 2024
Singers brought together by happiness research to take to the stage
The event is the grand finale of ground-breaking research by UWE Bristol and St George's Bristol exploring the links between singing and wellbeing.
![A sign with branding of the Future Space lab at UWE's Frenchay campus](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/future-space-expansion-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=EA4ACD0587C4C09E99C8DB97E1D4F4F4)
21 May 2024
Growth for tech innovation in Bristol as Future Space expands
UWE Bristol’s award-winning innovation centre, Future Space, has opened its doors to 10,000 square feet of brand-new office and laboratory facilities.
![A mother lies on a bed alongside her young baby](/-/media/uwe/images/news/motherhood-pandemic-adobestock-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=A5D13C5B88DEC68412A7FE9B32A3D1BD)
01 May 2024
The hidden work of new mothers exposed by the COVID-19 pandemic
New research has uncovered how the pandemic intensified and exposed the immense layers of unpaid work by mothers during maternity leave.
![Female with long fair hair with her back to camera holding a small brown dog in her arms, with the dog facing the camera over her shoulder](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/dog-theft-research-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=6B48D7A7D4C02FE382B0A4E65E6B75E4)
26 April 2024
Study reveals emotional turmoil experienced after dog theft is like that of a caregiver losing a child
A new study led by a UWE Bristol researcher has revealed that emotional turmoil experienced by dog owners after their pet has been stolen is like/ akin to that of losing a loved one such as a caregiver losing their child.
![A billboard in St Werbughs in Bristol shows children's illustrations and the words if racism vanished for day I'd wear my hair like this](/-/media/uwe/images/news/billboard-racism-vanished-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=AEF138B778B4ABA3532A6C5D2630EE94)
26 April 2024
New billboard to encourage conversations about what life might be like without racism
The billboard displays an illustration from the book ‘If Racism Vanished for a Day’, which explores the impact of racism on children's wellbeing.
![A female researcher dressed in protective clothing and safety goggles holding a pipette in a science laboratory](/-/media/uwe/images/news/news-items/research-concordat-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=C75E382A18894215622DD829F01C0DEC)
25 April 2024
UWE Bristol among first organisations to sign agreement to reduce environmental impacts of conducting research
UWE Bristol is among the first organisations to commit to a new national voluntary agreement to progressively embed environmental sustainability into all research and innovation practices.
![Representatives from UWE Bristol join Woodland Heritage and Forest Research with PhD student Alice Dibley](/-/media/uwe/images/news/woodland-heritage-phd-410x230.jpg?h=230&w=410&la=en&hash=45F19ADF3D96E7D660DDA620AEB3F667)
15 March 2024
UWE Bristol announces partnership PhD with Woodland Heritage
A Partnership PhD will research the effects of management practices on Acute Oak Decline and the rhizosphere microbiome of parkland oak trees.