1. Topic

  Direction and support of AQ Management by National Governments

2. Introduction

   

The principle of subsidiarity requires that any action is taken at the most appropriate level of governance. Therefore, whilst major decisions on the implementation of cleaner fuels or new engine technologies are generally taken at the European level (parliament/commission), and general strategic transport and industrial policies decided at a national level, there is a considerable element of air quality management which requires undertaking at the local level, on a city-scale.

As discussed in Topic Differences in responsibilities for air pollution between levels of government across Europe, the European Framework on Ambient Air Quality places responsibilities for AQM only on the shoulders of Member States (e.g. at a national government level). In order for the Member States to be confident of achieving the Limit Values (and confident that they have achieved them) they will need to be certain that appropriate measures are being taken at the city/local level. This Topic looks at ways in which this confidence can be achieved through the establishment of a clear framework for both the national and local authorities to see their actions.

3. Discussion

   

In order for Member States to be confident that the EU Limit Values will be achieved within all areas of their country two goals must be achieved:

· They must have a clear idea of what air quality is like (at a very fine scale) across all parts of the country;

· Where the former has shown that AQ is currently unlikely to meet the Limit Values it is essential that the national government is aware of possible actions being carried out with regard to improving it.

Topic Differences in responsibilities for air pollution between levels of government across Europe looks at how responsibilities have been transferred from the national governments of Member States to lower levels of government. This Topic differs in that it looks at the frameworks and assistance that can be provided to help/ensure that local government can meet the Limit Values.

Very few countries in Europe have managed to implement a successful framework for carrying out this process. The UK is regularly cited as having one of the best examples of a framework and so the following outline will be based mainly on elements that have been implanted there.

· Statutory Responsibilities – Probably the most important driver for ensuring that Local Authorities put due priority on air quality work is by making it a statutory requirement. Environmental issues are regularly sidelined in favour of economic benefits and this is a reliable way in which local government air quality officers can have their standing within the council increased. In the UK clear responsibilities have been laid out for local government to make them carry out ‘Review and Assessments’ of their local air quality, declare ‘Air Quality Management Areas’ in any places where the UK AQ Objectives appear unlikely to be met, and then, where necessary, to devise local action plans N.B. UK Las only have a responsibility to ‘work towards’ meeting objectives – not to actually achieve them.

· Financial Resources – Many people might put this in first place – however, without statutory responsibilities or strong ring-fencing, it is unlikely that local government priorities would divert as much money as intended towards air quality work. Assistance with finances also becomes necessary one the legal requirements to do the work have been put in place.

· Guidance – Again, the imposition of a legal requirement to carry out certain air quality work requires further assistance to be put in place. In order for national governments to ensure that local government can be fairly expected to comply, there is a need for guidance to be issued to the Local Authorities clearly outlining how work should be carried out and to what standard. This is particularly important in terms of how monitoring and modelling should be carried out so that all work is of an acceptable standard and comparable. Basic guidance can be issued in the form of written manuals. However, in the UK and also in the Netherlands the national governments have set up special ‘helpdesks’ where air quality experts are employed to give targeted one-to-one advice to local authorities.

On top of basic Guidance, there is a wide range of work that National Governments can carry out to help local authorities to make adequate assessments of their air quality. These include:

Providing information on national background concentrations of pollution so that local resources can be focussed on identifying their locally generated components;

Disseminating information that is held at a national level on emissions from various sources;

Making any monitoring data collected at a national level easily available;

Ensuring that all Local Authorities and government agencies are briefed properly with regard to responsibilities to share information and generally behave in a co-operative manner (e.g. National transport/highways agencies must be briefed with regard to AQ responsibilities);

Providing training opportunities for Local Authority officers, as once statutory responsibilities are put in place for all Local Authorities there may well be a shortage of experienced staff;

· Additional powers can be granted to Local Authorities to help them improve air quality. Some of the powers set forward in the UK include: road-user charging, workplace parking levy, roadside emissions testing, and prevention of emissions from parked/idling vehicles.

· One of the final things that national governments can do is to raise air quality on their own (and the nation’s) agenda. By encouraging the use of public transport at a national level, and being seen to not have a transport policy based on building new roads, national governments can begin to create an environment where the car is not the primary form of transport and local authorities are not working in independent isolation to try and solve a problem that requires significant action at both a local AND national level.

4. Recommendation / Conclusion

   

· Due to need for action on air quality management to be undertaken at both a national and local level it is extremely desirable that a strong framework is imposed by national governments. This is in their interests as it will be they who will have to answer to the EU if Limit Values are not achieved.

· The framework should be set up so that it ensures that excessive actions are not required from authorities who may not have a serious air quality problem. At the same time though, it must ensure that all areas do pay at least the minimum attention necessary to this issue. Suitable direction should also ensure that all work is of suitable quality and in an easily comparable format. Again this is something that is in the interest of the national government.

· What is crucial in directing the process, is that the local authorities are not restricted in the extent to which they can choose to bring about air quality improvements. All direction and guidance should be on the basis of being enabling and not limiting, and should seek to ensure that all local authorities are in the position where they can, most efficiently and effectively, do the minimum required to achieve or maintain good air quality for their citizens

5. Examples / Further Reading

    Direction and Support by National Governments with AQ Management in Düsseldorf
Direction and Support by National Governments with AQ Management in Birmingham
Action plan to reduce the concentration of nitrogen dioxide in the county of Stockholm
Direction and Support by National Governments with AQ Management in Utrecht
Governmental interactions in Leipzig
National Reference Laboratory in Sweden
Direction and Support by National Governments with AQ Management in Venice

6. Additional Documents / Web Links

   

· General Assessment: http://www.uwe.ac.uk/aqm/review/index.html

· Modelling: http://www.casellastanger.com/JointProjects/DEFRA-Home.asp?jointprojectid=7

· Monitoring and Emissions: http://www.airquality.co.uk/archive/index.php

· Action Planning: http://www.casellastanger.com/JointProjects/DEFRA-Home.asp?jointprojectid=10

· Information and guidance for local authorities to help with Local Air Quality Management process in UK. http://www.uwe.ac.uk/aqm/review/index.html

· Tools to help local authorities carry out assessments of air quality.: http://www.airquality.co.uk/archive/laqm/laqm.php

· National UK archive of air pollution data/information: http://www.airquality.co.uk/

· Dutch consultancy contracted to provide assistance to local authorities with AQM issues: http://www.infomil.nl/

· UK national government air quality division webpage: http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/airquality/index.htm

· National Government help and guidelines:

· http://www.infomil.nl/ - Dutch consultancy contracted to provide assistance to local authorities with AQM issues.

· http://www.vrom.nl/ - Issues concerning the tasks of the Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning (land use) and the Environment

· http://www.rivm.nl/ - Technical reports on health and environment and measurements from national air quality stations

· http://www.platformschonevoertuigen.nl/ - Information about cleaner vehicles

· http://www.luchtkwaliteitsplan.nl/ - Exchanging platform (members) measures on air quality

· http:/www.bmu.bund.de/files/vo_begruendung.pdf[d1]

· Member States and air quality contacts: http://www.europa.eu.int/comm/environment/air/links.htm

· Italian Government Regional Affairs web site: http://www.governo.it/affariregionali/

· Italian Environment Ministry web site: http://www.minambiente.it/



Last Updated


 

21st January 2005

Back